1 Tygok

The Case For Torture By Michael Levin Essay

Michael Levin's The Case For Torture

In “The Case for Torture,” Michael Levin presents logical fallacies that originate at the authors desire to relate the importance of his message. Though his specific argument is a very plausible solution to a taboo problem, the manner in which he presents it has some fallacies that cause it to be unsupported
Levin argues that torture should be used on terrorist in order to save people from terrorism. He further implies that this is the morally correct thing to do, because it ensures the good of the people. While his argument would be plausible in a utilitarian society, it is formidable within the cultural ideals of America as democratic societies typically tend to obscure techniques that violate natural rights and or ethics. Hence, Levin works excessively in order to convince his audience of his position. He uses three extreme, hypothetical examples in which torture may be necessary. One being a situation with a terrorist on Manhattan Island plotting to detonate a bomb on July fourth, another being a bomber on a jet plane wanting his demands to be met, and the last, a polled scenario where a terrorist group kidnapped newborn infants from a hospital. He also states that torture should not be punishment for an attack, but rather means of preventing one from happening. He then states that there must be “clear guilt” in order for someone to torture for these purposes. Finally, he addresses that the implications that accepting torture into western culture will emit to the rest of the world are nonexistent and the democracy will not lose its way.
Levin attempts to persuade the reader that torture is the only way to ensure justice with the use of multiple fallacies in a single statement that include: the either-or-fallacy, a contradiction, and a loaded question. He asks “If the only way to save those lives is to subject the terrorist to the most excruciating possible pain, what grounds can there be for not doing so?” (Levin) Here he implies that torture is the only option. The use of the phrase “only way” leads the reader to believe that there is no room for other options when in actuality there is. In fact the author acknowledges this other option when he states that we could satisfy the demands of the terrorist. Therefore the statement is not only fallible because it limits options presented to reader, but also because it contradicts the statement Levin made earlier in the article. Further, Levin uses a loaded question to ask the audience to provide reasons why torture would not be ideal. However, the original premise that torture is the only way to save lives would have to be accepted by the audience in order to relieve the question of any implied answer. In fact, the false dilemma explained prior is inside of the loaded question. The question presents to the reader two answers; that torture is the only option and that there cannot be another option. Here, the question is posed in hopes of obtaining a predetermined answer that would allude to and...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

The case for cannabis Essay

1859 words - 7 pages The Case for CannabisWhat if there were a plant that could produce more than four times as much paper as a tree with 60-80% less chemicals, make a fabric stronger, lighter, and more resilient than cotton, require little or no pesticides to grow, replace every fossil fuel with a cleaner burning, renewable biomass, and relieve people with serious illnesses of at least some of their maladies? What if you were told that this plant does...

The Case for the Grade Essay

991 words - 4 pages I put a great deal of effort into my diagnostic essay The Case for the Grade. I had some anxiety about writing it, as this was my first essay for my first online class. However, I studied the Rubric and the subject essay thoroughly. I followed the prompt explicitly. The prompt states, “Your job is to read the course rubric (under ‘course content’) together with the piece below. Once you’ve done this, you will write a two-to-three page essay...

Cons of Genetic Engineering: The Case Against Perfection by Michael J. Sandal

1865 words - 7 pages Genetic engineering includes altering heredity structures of living organisms and food products to provide the substance with certain traits which may appeal more to one. Other desired characteristics with regards to the Human genome project scientists have had a breakthrough in science. Now scientists are able to create synthetic organs for transplants and prevent disease by manipulating genes. According to Grocery manufacturers of...

The Case for Legalizing Drugs

3046 words - 12 pages Man, as a creature, is inherently bored. Since the dawn of time, it has been the natural instinct ofman to find alternative methods to enhance his being. The many means by which man has turned toinclude sex, gambling, and the consumption of substances beyond the requirements of nutrition. Theconsumption of substances can be further broken down into legal and illegal substances. Thequestion then becomes, who are we...

Greenspan - The Case for the Defense

514 words - 2 pages Greenspan - The Case for the DefenseMy fascination with the Judicial System Structure of todays society was furtheredand strengthened after reading and analyzing the works of Edward Greenspan. Thesuperbly written biography recollecting past cases and important events in Greenspan'slife allowed myself, the reader, to learn more about...

The case for and against capital punishment

1036 words - 4 pages Capital punishment, also known as death penalty or execution, is the sentence that a criminal must fulfil preceding committing a capital crime. Capital crimes consist of mass murders, treachery and other offenses. The English word ’Capital’ is derived from Latin ‘Capitalis’ meaning the head – ‘caput’ as the sentence was normally served by decapitating the criminal. The sentence has been in practise for thousands of years, used in almost every...

The Case for Principle-Based Accounting

1011 words - 4 pages Samuel J. Ochieng DQ Week 2 Discussion on whether to use rules or principles based accounting standards Stakeholders in accounting include and are not limited to shareholders/investors in the company, regulators, lenders, customers and the accounting profession, just to mention a few. All the stakeholders have interest in high quality accounting reports that enable them to make a fair judgment whenever they need to make a decision on regarding a...

The case for and against genetic engineering

962 words - 4 pages The case for and against genetic engineering I will look at the case for and against the use of genetic engineering and make a conclusion on whether or not I believe that it is right. As I believe in genetic engineering, I will start buy looking at the reasons that support it. The main reason that I support genetic engineering is that this technology has dramatically improved our ability to treat and even cure...

The Case for Mandatory Voting in Canada

3118 words - 12 pages Since the turn of the twenty first century, in Canada voter turnout has made a significant and consecutive decline. In the last five federal elections on average only sixty-one per cent of eligible voters voted. If each eligible citizen voted in an election the government would be on par with the primary interests of the people. The easiest way to achieve this objective is by implementing a compulsory voting system. Mandatory voting systems...

The Theme of Jorneying in For A Journey by Alan Brownjohn and To The Virginian Voyage by Michael Drayton

1812 words - 7 pages The Theme of Jorneying in For A Journey by Alan Brownjohn and To The Virginian Voyage by Michael Drayton "The death of fear is in doing what you fear to do." 'Journey' is an encompassing word. The connotations of the word "journey" are:- trying to get from one place to another, going somewhere different to where you usually go, an adventure, a journey can be life itself. It is said that many people are afraid and ...

Analysis of Michael Moore’s Treatment of His Subject Matter within the Documentaries Bowling for Columbine and Fahrenheit 911

3556 words - 14 pages Analysis of Michael Moore’s Treatment of His Subject Matter within the Documentaries Bowling for Columbine and Fahrenheit 911 “A documentary may be as a film or television or radio programme that provides factual information about a subject. Typically, a documentary is a journalistic record of events presented on screen.” The main conventions of documentaries tend to be that the documentary has voice-over commentary;...

 

It isgenerallyassumedhat torfuresimpermissible, throwbackoamorebrutal age.Enlightenedsocietiesejecttoutright,and regimessuspected f using t risk thewrath of theUnitedStates.I believe hisattitudesunwise.There are situations n which torture s not merelypermissibleut morally mandatory.Moreover, hese ituations removing rom the realmofimasination ofact.Supposeterroristhashidden an atomic bomb onManhattan sland which willdetonate tnoonon July4 unless ..here ollow the usualdemandsor moneyand eleasefhis friendsfromail.Suppose,urther, hathe iscaughtat 10 a.m. on the fateful day,butpreferringdeath o failure,won't disclosewhere he bomb s. What do we do? f we follorvdueprocess,wait for his lawyer,arcaignhim,millions ofpeoplewill die.fthe onlywayto save hoselives is to subjectheterroristo the most excruciatingpossiblepain,whatgroundscan herebe for notdoing so? suggesthere arenone. n any case, askyouto face hequestionwithan openmind.Torturing the terrorists unconstitutional? robably.Butmillions oflivessurely outweighconstitutionality.Torturesbarbaric?Mass murder s far more barbaric. ndeed,ettingmillions of innocentsdie in deferenceo one who flaunts hisguiltis moral cowardice,anunwillingnesso dirty one'shands. fyoucaught he terrorist,couldyousleepnightsknowing thatmillions died becauseoucouldn'tbringyourselfo apply theelectrodes?Onceyouconcedehat torfure sustifiedin extremecases,ouhaveadmitted hathedecisiono use ortures a matter of balancing nnocent ives against he meansneeded osave hem.You mustnow face more realistic casesnvolving more modestnumbers.Someonelantsa bombon aumbo jet.He alonecan disarm t, andhis demandsannotbemet(ortheycan,we refuse oset aprecedentyyieldingto histhreats).Sureiywe can, wemust,do anything othe extorticinisto save hepassengers.orv canwe tell 300,or100,or10peoplewho'neverasked o beputin danger,I'mson1,ou'llhave o die n agony,weustcouldn'tbringourselveso . .."Here arehe resultsof annformalpollaboutathird,hypothetical,case.Suppose terroristgoupkidnappedanewbornbaby from a hospital. asked our mothers f theywouldapproveof torturingkidnappers f that were necessaryogetheir own newbornsback.Allsaid .es.he most"liberal"addine hat shewould ike to administert herself.I amnot advocatingorture aspunishment.Punishment saddressedo deeds rrevocablypast.Rather, am advocatingorture as an acceptablemeasure orpreventingutureeviis. Sounderstood,t is far lessobjectionablehan many extantpunishments.Opponents f the death

Leave a Comment

(0 Comments)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *